Of these two options, which would you recommend for the rhythm guitarist in my classic rock side project?

Option 1:
MI Audio Crunchbox
Mojo Hand Huckleberry
Analogman Beano Boost
Danelectro Fish'n'Chips 7-band Eq
MXR Custom Shop Script Phase 90
Boss DD-20

Option 2:
Fulltone OCD
Analogman Peppermint Fuzz
Boss GE-7 w/ Sniper Mod
Retro-sonic Phaser
ThunderTweak Delay

He is running a Ceriatone 18w Plexi w/ an effects loop mod into a Marshall 1960 TV cab and a Fender Super Reverb.

Also, for those of you that are keeping up with my gear, the AC30, Mesa MKIII, Orange cab, American Std. Strat, and PRS Custom 24 got stolen from the band's practice facility. However,insurance covered the cost, so I am picking up a Budda Superdrive 18 head and a Marshall 1960 TV cab.
number 2 for sure, and i cant belive all that stuff got stolen, i know your insurance got it covered but still thats nice stuff.
It's okay, the only thing I'm really missing is the PRS. I do have enough cash to replace it. Fortunately my 335 is intact; if that got stolen, I would kill a man.

Also, Im going to switch to the more...controllable(?) ... Analogman SunFace Fuzz