#1
Since I always see people arguing about who is better whenever one of these bands it mentioned, I decided to make a thread dedicated to just arguing about the pros and cons of each band. Talk about Megadeths's many guitarists versus Kirk, Dave's and Jame's vocals, the better albums, etc. Let the fighting begin.
Quote by rancidryan
Do they come with heroin because I heard thats the only reason Dave Mustaine used them


"The power of the riff compels me"
Bury Me In Smoke
#2
I just laugh whenever I think that Dave's only goal in life is to make a better band than metallica..... that should kind of show you who wins this debate
#4
your an idiot
*reported*
Vikings? What Vikings? We are but poor, simple farmers. The village was burning when we got here, and the people must have slain themselves.
#5
Quote by Shadow_Hawk
I just laugh whenever I think that Dave's only goal in life is to make a better band than metallica..... that should kind of show you who wins this debate


Screw you!

Megadeth till 'deth!

Dave never sold out! Made 1000x times better music! Totaly outplays Metallica!
James sings Country, Lars is bald, Kirk sux. Dave is the true metal God!

All hail Megadave!
#6
Quote by GoodCharloteSux
n00b, this will get closed ASAP

Why? Its just a place for people to vent their constant urges of arguing who is better instead of putting it in places where it is unwanted. This thread is doing nothing wrong.
Quote by rancidryan
Do they come with heroin because I heard thats the only reason Dave Mustaine used them


"The power of the riff compels me"
Bury Me In Smoke
#8
Quote by strat07
Screw you!

Megadeth till 'deth!

Dave never sold out! Made 1000x times better music! Totaly outplays Metallica!
James sings Country, Lars is bald, Kirk sux. Dave is the true metal God!

All hail Megadave!


as much as id love to sit here arguing with you
this threads gonna be closed in the next few minutes
Vikings? What Vikings? We are but poor, simple farmers. The village was burning when we got here, and the people must have slain themselves.
#9
Quote by COBHC6
your an idiot
*reported*

How am I an idiot? I'm not saying one band is better than the other. I love both bands. I just thought this would be a good idea, jeez. Sorry Mr. Hardass.

Edit: This isn't really a "versus" thread actually. Fans of both bands can say what they like and dislike about each band.
Quote by rancidryan
Do they come with heroin because I heard thats the only reason Dave Mustaine used them


"The power of the riff compels me"
Bury Me In Smoke
Last edited by Flying Afros at Mar 22, 2008,
#10
Quote by Flying Afros
How am I an idiot? I'm not saying one band is better than the other. I love both bands. I just thought this would be a good idea, jeez. Sorry Mr. Hardass.

Edit: This isn't really a "versus" thread actually. Fans of both bands can say what they like and dislike about each band.

well
thats good for you
but this IS a versus thread, which is against the rules
theres respective threads for both bands, and we dont need a thread for fanboys of each band to continuously bitch at each other over which band is better
i suggest you close this
Vikings? What Vikings? We are but poor, simple farmers. The village was burning when we got here, and the people must have slain themselves.
#11
I think since the 90's onwards, Megadeth has been better than Metallica because of consistency with albums and just all around better music. Also, Megadeth were more metal and faster in the 90's than Metallica were
#13
Quote by strat07
Screw you!

Megadeth till 'deth!

Dave never sold out! Made 1000x times better music! Totaly outplays Metallica!
James sings Country, Lars is bald, Kirk sux. Dave is the true metal God!

All hail Megadave!

Close minded freak.
#15
Quote by strat07
Screw you!

Megadeth till 'deth!

Dave never sold out! Made 1000x times better music! Totaly outplays Metallica!
James sings Country, Lars is bald, Kirk sux. Dave is the true metal God!

All hail Megadave!

+1 !!!

Dave is the only one still delivering the goods ! I can't wait to hear their new stuff !!!
#17
Megadeth, made mediocre music up until 1990, and poor music after
Metallica, made **** music up until 1990, and worse music after

So Megadeth, the better of two **** bands, prevails
#18
Quote by Spockleatard
Megadeth>Metallica



+9999999999
Fender American Special Telecaster
Blackstar HT-5
Wren and Cuff Tall Font Russian
BBE Sonic Stomp
Mojo Hand FX Recoil Delay
Empress ParaEQ
#19
Kreator > both of em
The Kovenant of Terror, Marshal of the Legion of Metal.


Quote by GID (Shamrock)
Br00tal, Terror Kovenant=metal's king

#21
Dave Mustaine is extremely unqiue vocal wise...literally never heard anyone even similar
James has just gone down the ****ter recently, but his vocals on Kill 'Em All still make me cringe with hapiness every listen.

Megadeth's Guitar work > Metallica Guitar Work
Megadeth's Drumming >>>>>>>>>>> Metallica's Drumming
Megadeth's Vocals > Metallica's Vocals (nowadays, in the very early days, Metallica wins)

Kill 'Em All & Ride the Lightning > KIMB...ABIG
Peace Sells...But Who's Buying > Master of Puppets (by so much of a ****ing long shot)
...And Justice For All >>>> SFSGSW
The Black Album = Countdown
Rust in Peace >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Black Album
Megadeth's 90's releases owned Metallica's

The final decision:

United Abominations >>>>> St. Anger


In the end, Megadeth wins for overall consistency, and progressing farther into their catalogue, they get even better...unlike Metallica who progressively got worse.
R.I.P. Charles Michael "Evil Chuck" Schuldiner
B. May 13 1967 - D. December 13 2001

Quote by eggsandham2
cuz ppl hate how power metal they are cuz they think its "gay" or w.e, which is immature and dirogitory
#22
HAHA, I laugh in the faces at the noob who said I couldn't make this thread.

And to answer MHDrunk, I got both Dave Mustaine's and James Hetfield's approval on this.

My opinion of Metallica's 90s albums: I don't accuse them of "selling out." They are the band; they are in charge. Random fans can't tell them what they can and can't do. So what if James has country influences and it shows in some of the songs? It's their music!
Quote by rancidryan
Do they come with heroin because I heard thats the only reason Dave Mustaine used them


"The power of the riff compels me"
Bury Me In Smoke
#23
Anyone else pointed out "No Vs. threads" ?
Oh good.
*reports anyway*

Oh and to be on topic

Metallica made great music until they sold out, then they made OK music.
Megadeth made great music, until...they made more great music.

Dave Mustaine never had to go into therapy because he couldn't take the pressure
Dave Mustaine never had to edit a documentary so Lars Ulrich looked like a cunt.
Megadeth never took 5 years to record an album, only to release a cd case containing only disc shaped feces.

End result
Megadeth is teh winnar
Last edited by Magero at Mar 22, 2008,
#26
Quote by Magero
At least Dave realised he'd fucked up and went back to his roots STRAIGHT AWAY.

Yes that's true. Do you guys think TWNAH was a good album? To be honest, I've never heard it.

And whats the point of reporting a thread. Do you get satisfaction out of it? Do you get a cookie from the mods for reporting? It makes no sense. This thread actually has a purpose.
Quote by rancidryan
Do they come with heroin because I heard thats the only reason Dave Mustaine used them


"The power of the riff compels me"
Bury Me In Smoke
#27
Quote by Flying Afros
Yes that's true. Do you guys think TWNAH was a good album? To be honest, I've never heard it.

And whats the point of reporting a thread. Do you get satisfaction out of it? Do you get a cookie from the mods for reporting? It makes no sense. This thread actually has a purpose.


Cause it's against the rules. Many other people have done this before you, and all of those threads were closed.

On another note, The World Needs A Hero was ok. A lot better than Risk, much worse than The System Has Failed imo.
Quote by severed-metal

You're losing interest because you're simply not gay enough. Which leads me to believe you aren't cut out for metal.
#28
I would like to point out that Dave's appearance on Duck Dodgers instantly lifts him to god status and thus he >'s Metallica singlehandedly.
#29
Quote by The Frayed Ends
I would like to point out that Dave's appearance on Duck Dodgers instantly lifts him to god status and thus he >'s Metallica singlehandedly.

In addition to that, don't forget all his great Mustainisms.
Quote by AvengedThrice
Rengori, I hereby name you GOD. Bow down fuckers.
Quote by Vittu0666
Quote by ShredtoBed
SO if Janne and Alexi did a gay porn, would I be the only one willing to buy it?

That's a dumb question, you know everyone in here would buy it too. I know I would!

Search for Artefact.
#30
Megadeth, Metallica doesn't come close

Megadeth excells in every instrument while Metallica is just mediocre
Quote by powerhead
Mentallica, i think you just made my drive shank crank

Quote by beadhangingOne


You sir, are a true hero.


Quote by silversoulcage
Dude, seriously, you're an ass hole. That place where **** comes out, yea that's you man.