So, I've got a Little Big Muff that I really liked the sound in the noisy guitar shop when I bought it. However, I've discovered that I only really get the kind of sounds that I like when I keep the sustain almost off and my guitar volume waaaaay down. I just don't like the (what to seems to me to be) the really high gainyness of it. I only have one or two really good sounds out of it. I'd like some recommendations on other good fuzzes, maybe some that a little more low-gain, for more like fuzzed-out blues kind of stuff, I guess. Assume a price limit of something like $200USD.
BOSS BD-2? It's more of an overdrive but it sounds like what you're looking for. Try it out, I think you'd like it.