#1
ok. my friend compared clarinet. to guitar. AND DRUMS
in a way of. how you play them


and im not saying any are better than the other


seriously. what do you think
Last edited by reneeGHOUL at Apr 3, 2008,
#2
How exactly did he compare them, they are all musical instruments after all

I also didn't know that arguments have sexual orientations.
#3
Just so you know. A full-stop =/= a comma.

You can compare and contrast them....but you can't say one is harder or better.
Everyone becomes a genius when they join UG
#6
k...
Quote by doggy_hat
This chick that looked like shrek ****ed me while I was passed out on xanax. I screamed when I woke up.
#10
I think
You stink
Hehehehehe.

Could you elaborate your problem for us because it's currently ambiguous what your point of discussion might be.
Quote by Kensai
IF YOU TYPE WITH BIG LETTERS YOUR POINT WILL COME ACROSS EASIER!

Seriously wtf was that?
#11
lol

guitar is the instrument of the working class man who isn't talented enough to play anything else
#12
It's obviously a gay argument. Talking about how Brad Pitt is and such, comparing penis sizes too.
#13
Their all musical instruments and their all made of wood with metal parts... I think I can see where he's coming from
I've Made You A Drawing of a Giraffe Fucking an Elephant. Notice How His Moustache Looks Just Like Mine.

Your Mother's Got a Penis
#14
Quote by thedudemeister
guitar is better, its the most versatile of all 3.

Well if you added a microphone and some sort of processor to a clarinet, I'm sure it would be versatile as well....
Everyone becomes a genius when they join UG
#15
Quote by reneeGHOUL
seriously. what do you think


I think you should never again use 'gay' to do with something you dislike.
#16

OK, well a clarinet has keys, a guitar has strings and drums are something you hit.
A piano has 'keys', which operates a mechanism which 'hits' 'strings.'

So that makes them all comparative.
#17
Quote by Liam4
How exactly did he compare them, they are all musical instruments after all

I also didn't know that arguments have sexual orientations.



i prety much told him this

you have to worry about two hands to get the sound. therefore. that part is harder
but. the frets are heaps easy to learn

on clarinet though
its easier to get the sound because you play it with your mouth. one thing.
but you have to memorise 40 different combinations
#18
Quote by ctb
I think you should never again use 'gay' to do with something you dislike.


i changed it
#19
Quote by faultyy
Their all musical instruments and their all made of wood with metal parts... I think I can see where he's coming from



it was more of a

how you play it way. not what they're made of
#20
whats wrong with comparing them?
your basically saying that guitar is too good for them which means YOUR comparing them...

ay?
ay?
huh?
#21
Quote by EdawMail
whats wrong with comparing them?
your basically saying that guitar is too good for them which means YOUR comparing them...

ay?
ay?
huh?


i play them. and im not saying any is better than the other
#22
Quote by reneeGHOUL
i play them. and im not saying any is better than the other


then whats your problem with your friend comparing them?
#23
Quote by reneeGHOUL
i prety much told him this

you have to worry about two hands to get the sound. therefore. that part is harder
but. the frets are heaps easy to learn

on clarinet though
its easier to get the sound because you play it with your mouth. one thing.
but you have to memorise 40 different combinations


And with drums, you have to master different rhythm techniques, not fuck up at all, and keep all 4 limbs in perfect sync.

Your argument has zero validity.
#24
You're forgetting that I mentioned that every SOUND had a note, the argument started with time signatures and you said that time signatures on clarinet were easier than guitar, and after telling you that it's about how proficient you are at the instrument (I play guitar, but completely sucked at recorder) that makes you able to play a certain time signature well.

A few sentences later, I say that I gave up recorder because I blew too hard (no pit, no, stop before you start) and got bad notes, and you go on to tell me that you get a squeak with a clarinet, I tell you that ANY sound at ALL that's ever made will have a note whether it wavers crazily over an octave or just stays at pitch, for it to have sound, there must be a note.

Drums have notes, only when they're struck, the skins vibrate and produce sound but the "note" wavers so fast that no certain note can be identified, it just vibrates too fast.

Pretty much that.
#25
Quote by EdawMail
then whats your problem with your friend comparing them?



because im trying to get the point across that.
time signatures are easier to control on clarinet.
#26
Quote by XianXiuHong
because I blew too hard




im sorry thats just funny

on topic: you can't compare 3 different instruments they're all good in their own way
#27
1. Using gay in the wrong sense

2. Respect the opnions of others

3. There's nothing wrong with clarinet

Quote by hazzmatazz
youmakemesmile...

Quote by sebastian_96
Today I stole a girls tampons for being such an annoying bitch.





MUFC


My love for you
Is like a truck
Berserker.
#28
Quote by XianXiuHong
You're forgetting that I mentioned that every SOUND had a note, the argument started with time signatures and you said that time signatures on clarinet were easier than guitar, and after telling you that it's about how proficient you are at the instrument (I play guitar, but completely sucked at recorder) that makes you able to play a certain time signature well.

A few sentences later, I say that I gave up recorder because I blew too hard (no pit, no, stop before you start) and got bad notes, and you go on to tell me that you get a squeak with a clarinet, I tell you that ANY sound at ALL that's ever made will have a note whether it wavers crazily over an octave or just stays at pitch, for it to have sound, there must be a note.

Drums have notes, only when they're struck, the skins vibrate and produce sound but the "note" wavers so fast that no certain note can be identified, it just vibrates too fast.

Pretty much that.


because you said ive dont music longer than you,
and im telling you that means jack****.
#29
Quote by wylde_overdrive
And with drums, you have to master different rhythm techniques, not fuck up at all, and keep all 4 limbs in perfect sync.

Your argument has zero validity.

your comment as zero validity.

because you say have to stretch fingers to play a note on drums


get it straight
#30
Quote by thedudemeister
guitar is better, its the most versatile of all 3.


Oh I'll show you how versatile a clarinet can be...

wait..
Hurp De Durp
#31
Quote by reneeGHOUL
because you said ive dont music longer than you,
and im telling you that means jack****.



You've actually taken more formal training than me, I only had lessons for the better part of a year (8 months) and the rest is self-taught.
#32
Quote by thedudemeister
guitar is better, its the most versatile of all 3.

not really.

you put a clarinet together wrongly and its dead
#33
Quote by XianXiuHong
You've actually taken more formal training than me, I only had lessons for the better part of a year (8 months) and the rest is self-taught.

but you spend pretty much every second of your spare time playing.

i dont have that time to do that
#35
Quote by XianXiuHong
Playing is different to theory, I think I know less theory than you >.>



exactly. you have time to practise

dude.
apparantly. i have natural talent.
but i still practise.
not as much as you htogh

so. you have time to get bette than me
#37
Quote by XianXiuHong
Aren't you always on DeviantArt anyway?


when im on deviant art
im either playing guitar.
playig clarinet
or. doing homework
#39
Quote by Liam4
FFS stop using full stops at completely random intervals.

why, .
shoulD (.)
he


.
^Note: Probably sarcastic
Gear
Schecter Blackjack C1-FR
Few Agile 8-strings
Ormsby Hypemachine 2014 otw!!

Carvin X-100B
axe-fx II

W.A musicians FTW
Quote by crisisinheaven
Deep*Kick. You have destroyed every concept of life I've ever had.
#40
Take your dick measuring contests to the playground kiddies.
<Dobzilla> because "when you were born, they thought yo' momma shit herself."
<Frehnchy> ...
<esther_mouse> ...
<Rankles> ...
<RaNdOm-FeLiX> ...
<Dobzilla>