So I was typing an EXTREMELY long crit for EVERY SONG so you could get some damn solid feedback, but when I hit quick reply I was logged out for inactivity and I pretty much lost EVERYTHING . I still feel that I should sum up everything because bands like their commentary.

I loved the style you guys are running with. The influences definitely are diverse within songs. Only downfall was that the ambient segments lacked life at moments and sounded like they were 'saved' by the heavy follow-ups. Also don't really think you need another guitarist. A bassist will bring out more melody and life in your ambient parts in the music, but other than that you should be fine.

Also, get your vocalist to show more climax in "Firefly" when the drums kick in! Everything falls together so well but he has the same sound as when the beginning of the song is playing.


^^^ My band, Silent Surrender. Also open for critique.

Schecter C-1 XXX
Squier Fender Stratocaster
Peavey 6505+
Marshall 1960A Lead Cabinet
Peavey Studio Pro 112
MXR Carbon Copy

Check out my band:www.myspace.com/silentsurrendertx