I was the first person to vote to reject your tab. I am sorry because it does look like you worked hard on it. I don't like voting to reject anybody who tries to make a serious tab, but sometimes there isn't a place for them. (In my opinion, based on the circumstances not on the content of your tab)
The reasons I voted to reject it were the fact that there are 8 versions. Some of those versions are highly rated. 5 star 33 votes is a lot. Even 5 star 8 votes is a lot and there are two of those so there are 3 five star tabs of this song. And 5 others. The rules used to state that you should not submit songs that have 5+ versions unless you can prove they are all wrong. (Can't find that wording in the rules anymore)
Second, I felt that your tab was very similar in content to the first tab, similar enough that accepting your tab was not a good choice.
I see that you have appealed your tab. My part in the process is done, I can only vote once in either direction unless you get rejected again and resubmit. (Full disclosure: as far as I personally am concerned I wouldn't reject you again but neither would I approve)
There are still other basic formatting issues with your tab that would have gotten it rejected even if there were zero other versions. Here is a link to the rules outline. https://www.ultimate-guitar.com/contribution/help/rubric#iii
For one thing instead of putting "now just repeat chords!" you need to put the chords over all the lyrics. That is the formatting standard.
You aren't supposed to have other characters with your chords like . and * If you edit your tab by hand so that your edit page looks like this [ch]G[/ch]. and [ch]Em7[/ch]* you *might* get to keep them, but some moderators may not allow even this. When you check "preview" the chord names should turn blue.
In your case I would leave them out entirely because if people listen to the song they can get that information with their ears, but I can see why you put them and I appreciate you trying to illustrate the song in detail.
As per the rules you will also be asked to label all the sections. You did label the intro but also put a label for the verses and the choruses.
If you fix these issues you will have a better chance of getting your tab approved, but I'm not sure how good of a chance. (Due to the 8 other versions)
I realize that it's frustrating and disappointing to get tabs rejected, so I'm sorry for that.
I think if a tab has too many one or two stars, they should be pulled. It would make room for new ones !!!
I agree, but that is not something that happens at this time as far as I know. By the way this is not the case for this tab. One 3 star and 2 no votes.