Providence review by Callisto

logo Ultimate Guitar
  • Released: Feb 18, 2009
  • Sound: 3
  • Lyrics: 5
  • Overall Impression: 3
  • Reviewer's score: 3.7 Poor
  • Users' score: 6.9 (19 votes)
Callisto: Providence

Sound — 3
There are two likely reasons you are reading this review. One reason is that the name piqued your interest and you wanted to take a quick look; the other is that you've heard Callisto before and you are salivating over the prospect of them releasing a new album. Now, I personally couldn't help but wait for another sublimely cold, dense powerhouse like their debut, 'True Nature Unfolds', but after 2006 saw the release of the slightly diluted 'Noir' and Callisto saw a change of vocalist, that was a little unreasonable. Progression is something that is both feared and revered, with nearly any band, and it pains me to say that in the case of 'Providence', a step seems to have been taken in the wrong direction. The focus of this album is a mellowed form of intensity, one which burns slowly and surely. I'm sure a description of that nature would be accompanied by words like 'art' or 'soundscape' in a press release, but unfortunately the reality is that very little happens on this record. Opener 'In Session' is a success in using sustain and droning for the purpose of a climax, however it is very quickly realised that every single track on 'Providence' is indistinguishable from the next. The crushing riffs that made Callisto's music so effective are now more or less gone; this is not even a metal album at all. The occasional screamed vocals and heavy guitars associate themselves only with the band's post-hardcore elements, not their sludge forte. I find that one of the problems with 'Noir' is that, whilst being musically strong, the production was a little too reserved to deliver the full force of what was being recorded. Frankly, Callisto have shot themselves in the foot with this one as the low end blurs into one long drone and the high end rounds off to a similar effect. The music itself is relatively barren of dynamics anyway, but the production job most certainly doesn't help.

Lyrics — 5
I think it would be very difficult for this album to work with the vocals of former vocalist Markus Myllykangas (who has now moved to guitars) as his strength and the strength of the band's riffs are symbiotic. As previously explained, the metal elements are almost completely gone and so with it a change in vocals had to be necessary...enter Jani Ala-Hukkala. A good 95% of this album's vocals are sung clean, with near-identical and unmemorable melodies smearing their mark all over the songs. There are some screams thrown in the mix on occasion, however they, much like the distorted guitars that accompany them, are still too low in the mix to have the devastating effect that they did on 'True Nature Unfolds'. Lyrically 'Providence' still has a firm footing; perhaps this is not such a compliment but the language lends itself kindly to the tone of the music and its visual representations on the album sleeve.

Overall Impression — 3
'Providence' is an album of ten tracks, all around the same length, and it plays for over an hour. There is an alarming suspicion in the back of my mind somewhere that the ten songs actually are the same, however I am incapable of confirming this as the songs are so uneventful that by the time I am listening to a second song I have forgotten how the first one went. There are two songs here that can hold interest and relative enjoyment for their entirety: 'Eastern Era' and 'In Session' and it is sad to think that either of these songs could have had their place on a quality Callisto album, however there are another 56 minutes of music to take into consideration and the collective dull flickering found in their musical energy is not nearly enough to support this album.

8 comments sorted by best / new / date

    This album is like a completely slow side of Cynic, but it's done poorly... Disappointed.
    I am a Callisto fan 'till death. This album was a huge disappointment, not to mention the new vocalist. Even so, I'm just too damn in love with the band's music after years of listening, to actually hate this album. Nevertheless, it's obvious that this album can never step up to Noir or True Nature Unfolds. But it's "just" a chapter in the chronicle.
    Mr. Hand
    It's growing on me. I was disappointed but some of the stuff on here is really good upon further listening. I still stand by my original opinion. It's a Great album... Just not a great Callisto album
    I dont know how good Callisto was but this album is not so bad that it deserves 3.7 average. Like a few people have said the album is a disappointment so i'll have to give their earlier material a chance.
    Every Callisto album is different from the last so I can't call this album a disappointment.It is a weird listen at first but if you give it repeated listens you end up finding a really great album.For anyone who buys this album listen to it at least 6 times and if you know anything about great songwriting you'll end up loving it.
    silly hats
    What, this album deserves so much more than 3.7. God forbid that a band tries something new. I personally really like this album.