X&Y review by Coldplay

logo Ultimate Guitar
  • Released: Jun 6, 2005
  • Sound: 5
  • Lyrics: 1
  • Overall Impression: 3
  • Reviewer's score: 3 Poor
  • Users' score: 7.7 (162 votes)
Coldplay: X&Y

Sound — 5
Problems ensue as the band doesn't do anything new with the sound. Still the low-end bass sounds are more resonant than the higher parts. The band delves deep into a space-like territory. The guitars are great in key songs. The break in "Talk" makes the song. But overall the songs are bland. "Fix You" might be one of Coldplay's best songs but it's the only song on this album that's due for repeat listening.

Lyrics — 1
The lyrics are trite. Anybody can write this stuff.

Overall Impression — 3
With better lyrics, this cd would have been better. But it's not all Chris Martin's fault. The songs go nowhere. "The Hardest Part" makes an attempt to be different but ends up sounding like a Keane outtake. "What If" has the blandest lyrics of the all, "What if there was no wrong... no right?" Even Martin has admitted that his shit stinks to high heavens as far as lyricism goes. They buckle underneath the pressure of trying to be the next U2. If you want good Coldplay, look to A Rush Of Blood to the Head. But this is not good Coldplay, this is substandard mediocre stuff that yuppies like. Huge disappointment.

4 comments sorted by best / new / date

    boyan89 : coldpaly suks
    sadly chris martin sings better than you chris martin plays piano better than you chris martin writes better lyrics than you
    Can i also add is a much better live artist aswell, i went and saw them in sydney, and they were F#####g awesome!!! they can realy rock when they want to!
    In response to a review here by an unregistered reviewer (just if he ever checks back here..)..... I think Coldplay are one of the best newer bands out there today. This is a good album. I am also a huge U2 fan, and I just wanted to ask an unregistered reviewer if he reads this.....what version of Sunday Bloody Sunday are you listening to? Cuz the drum beat in Square One is one of the least U2 like beats I have ever heard. Also, Talk sounds nothing like The Joshua Tree. Sorry, just a couple little problems with that. Overall a good album.
    chris martins voice is so boring and dull. the guitars boring as hell and the drummer is the only one who deserves to rock.