Sound — 4
My mate copied this for me and it's a good job he did, 'cause I'd never buy it. It's the worst CD I have. It's boring and really overated. It's too samey on the first disc and on the 2nd disc. The first track put me off completely, even though I have to listening to it. Best Of You which was released on single, was great, it's a good song and it's the only good thing about In Your Honor. There are various good points, some of the songs on disc 1 are similar to old Foo Fighter songs such as Last Song, old Foo Fighters was catchy and fun to listen to. It is also recorded well, 5 star recording quality and Grohl sounds good. It's layed out well but it just lacks simplicity and fun.
Lyrics — 8
The lyrics are good, even though there quite repetitive. The lyrics go well with the music, they fit in perfectly but there just a bit boring on some songs, I think most of it being to do with the actually music. David Grohl still has a good voice and teh ability to sing well. He's quite impressive on this album.
Overall Impression — 6
This is Foo Fighters' worst album yet. It's just so boring. The best songs on it are Best Of You, Last Song And In Your Honor. I don't love much about this, just the songs I mentioned. I hate the fact that it's boring, on 2 discs, and too same. If it was stolen I'd buy something else, maybe one of there first albums and then thank the person who stole it.