Life, Death, Live And Freedom review by John Mellencamp

logo Ultimate Guitar
  • Released: Jun 23, 2009
  • Sound: 7
  • Lyrics: 8
  • Overall Impression: 8
  • Reviewer's score: 7.7 Good
  • Users' score: 7.3 (4 votes)
John Mellencamp: Life, Death, Live And Freedom
1

Sound — 7
For the past few decades, John Mellencamp's blend of Heartland rock has connected with audiences well beyond Middle America. While the singer/songwriter/guitarist has certainly dabbled in more of the pop-rock genre, he most recently opted to explore a more stripped-down approach that had a distinct purpose. For the 2008 release Life Death Love and Freedom, Mellencamp told Rolling Stone, I realized our country has written some sad motherf**kin' songs. I wanted to see if I had it in me to write like that... I see darkness everywhere, and I have to write about it. I don't care if I just sell six records. All I can do is keep on writing songs and singing." He accomplished his goal in full, and hearing those songs performed on the concert CD Life Death LIVE and Freedom just seems to confirm the point that Mellencamp is still a man of the people. You may recall that the singer was one of the primary figures who spearheaded Farm Aid back in 1985, and in many ways that experience brought his folk rock roots to the forefront of the public eye. Mellencamp's latest material hearkens back to that era, but it also has a more weathered, cynical feel to it. Hearing the songs performed on a sterile studio release is one thing, but the new material is better suited for an audience. In some moments Mellencamp is so convincing that you could see him being right at home among the folk rock icons of the 1960's. Although there are only eight song selections on the live CD (as compared with the 14 tracks on the studio release), they still are engaging and heartfelt. Interestingly enough, many of the songs on the live release were actually recorded before the studio full-length even hit store shelves. Recorded at Los Angeles' Greek Theatre, Philadelphia's Mann Music Center, Toronto's Air Canada Centre, and the Centrium in Red Deer (Alberta, Canada), you get a wide variety of dates that blend in seamlessly together. There is hardly any banter to be heard, putting the spotlight on the songs. The opening number If I Die Sudden, although a fairly low-key, grooving rock tune at first listen, is still one of the most energetic among the eight selections. It's a solid song, but Mellencamp seems most comfortable in the unplugged, folk rock genre. The tracks Don't Need This Body, Young Without Lovers, and A Ride Back Home are easily the best selections on the CD because they are also the most understated. With the former two being straight acoustic numbers, it becomes all about the emotions and the lyrical content, which as Mellencamp promised, is a little on the depressing side. If you're a fan of Hurt So Good or Crumblin' Down, be aware that Mellencamp has left the rocker side of himself by the wayside. It's not a bad change by any means, and if you've felt a little beaten down by life, you'll probably appreciate the new direction. The fact that there are only eight tracks is somewhat disappointing, but the retail price does reflect the smaller quantity.

Lyrics — 8
The weathered, cynical side of Mellencamp is surprisingly effective. When you hear him sing such lines as, Well, all my friends are sick or dying; And I'm here all by myself; All I got left is a head full of memories (Don't Need This Body), it's both chilling and relatable. At the age of 57, the singer still could have plenty of years of performing ahead of him, but I'm sure he is quite cognizant that many of his fans (who haven't led a charmed life) can relate to a more introspective approach in the lyrical content.

Overall Impression — 8
Mellencamp had a monster hit with Pink Houses back in 1983, and that track certainly foreshadowed his current musical choices. But the material you'll hear on Life Death LIVE and Freedom goes into a much darker, downtrodden area than the aforementioned his single. While Jena and My Sweet Love are a few exceptions, the bulk of the tracks are the kind of music that makes for a great companion piece for a bottle of whiskey. There's a bluesy quality mixed in with the folk rock element, and although somewhat of a downer, still seems to work amazingly well for Mellencamp.

10 comments sorted by best / new / date

    Goz_Begins
    Jena is a stupid song.....why do celebs jump on these bandwagons.....remember the hoopla about the west memphis 3
    DarkfnTemplar1
    John Cougar Mellencamp killed legitamate rock and roll in 1982 with "Jack and Diane." Since then, producers have allowed sub par music to become potential "#1's." He's untalented and should never be on this site. If you think this post is spam/flamming, then you obivously have no idea what rock really is.
    The_Paranoia
    DarkfnTemplar1 wrote: John Cougar Mellencamp killed legitamate rock and roll in 1982 with "Jack and Diane." Since then, producers have allowed sub par music to become potential "#1's." He's untalented and should never be on this site. If you think this post is spam/flamming, then you obivously have no idea what rock really is.
    I know what rock is and I like Mellencamp.
    guitarsftw
    DarkfnTemplar1 wrote: John Cougar Mellencamp killed legitamate rock and roll in 1982 with "Jack and Diane." Since then, producers have allowed sub par music to become potential "#1's." He's untalented and should never be on this site. If you think this post is spam/flamming, then you obivously have no idea what rock really is.
    i know what rock is, i listen to it everyday, and putting on some JCM has always satisfied me.
    harpy1976
    hey templar, i don't think you know what rock is if your dissing on melloncamp. sure he has put out some bubble-gummy stuff, but hes still rock-n-roll to the core. i suppose people who love creedence clearwater revival and muddy waters don't know what rock is either, huh!
    DarkfnTemplar1
    Wow, just proves how little people know. All wrong. And how dare you put Cougar in the same sentence as rock greats? John Fogerty would shoot himself if he saw this.
    The_Paranoia
    DarkfnTemplar1 wrote: Wow, just proves how little people know. All wrong. And how dare you put Cougar in the same sentence as rock greats? John Fogerty would shoot himself if he saw this.
    Sorry, I forgot that you were crowed King of Music last week. Aren't opinions just overrated?
    TwistedLogic
    JCM knows who he is and I respect him for that. I love his music for the most part. I was raised on classic rock, own a vinyl copy of American Fool, and appriciate that he moves in different styles in his career. If he beleives in what he recorded it is likely decent material that I will give a shot. Getting older I understand how life sometimes beats you down.
    walk_tall_87
    DarkfnTemplar1 wrote: Wow, just proves how little people know. All wrong. And how dare you put Cougar in the same sentence as rock greats? John Fogerty would shoot himself if he saw this.
    Then why did John Fogerty do a tour with John Mellencamp in 2005. I respect peoples opinions and my opinion is that John Mellencamp is definately one of the greats. His lyrics rank with the best in my book and I totally agree with you twistedlogic!