Watershed review by Opeth

logo Ultimate Guitar
  • Released: Jun 3, 2008
  • Sound: 10
  • Lyrics: 10
  • Overall Impression: 10
  • Reviewer's score: 10 Gem
  • Users' score: 9.3 (215 votes)
Opeth: Watershed
2

Sound — 10
Watershed, in every way possible, sounds like an album condensed to its bare vitals. A popular criticism often leveled at the group by non-believers has finally been addressed; the band has been known to jam on a particular groove to the point just shy of overstaying its welcome. It's a very fine line to walk, and the band has had extensive practice on this balancing beam over the years, yet the haters seem to feel the 10+ min compositions drag too long. Well, for the first time the songs have been cut down to barest possible length without tarnishing the amazing quality the band has been known for since it's conception.

Lyrics — 10
Songs like The Lotus Eater transition from movement to movement at such an alarming rate compared to past compositions, that while your brain is wrapping itself around what the hell just happened, you're already being assaulted by the next riff or soothed by the next acoustic, keyboard laced passage. It's an utter overload of brilliance in a shortened time-span that keeps Watershed from fully sinking in on the first several listens, revealing veiled nooks and crannies with each subsequent exploration. This condensed style is a double-edged sword however, as it drags along the only criticism one can shoot at the album; When it's over, it just feels like a song is missing. This is completely the fault of the band for spoiling us over the years with grand 60+ min opuses, while Watershed clocks in at a paltry 54 min. I can't help but feel gipped a bit by this, especially since most of these songs feel like they could go on for several more minutes and explore even more territory than the vast amounts of ground they already cover. Mikael Akerfeldt's vocals are even better this time around in every area possible. His clean vocals are more heat-felt and shiver-inducing than ever, and the death growls are even more rich and guttural, further cementing him as the best goddamn voice in contemporary metal right next to Mikael Stanne. The other notable change is the keyboards; While Per Wilberg's keys were a welcome addition to the atmospherics on Ghost Reveries, they admittedly felt detachable and tacked on. This time around, the keys have been completely integrated into the band's sound with such seamlessness, that you're left wondering how they ever got by without them. The departure of drummer extraordinare Martin Lopez and long-time guitarist Peter Lingren haven't left a scratch on the band's sound, contrary to the expectations of many, proving once and for all that Akerfeldt is still the indispensable core of the outfit. Though they will be dearly remembered and missed, Fredrik Akesson (ex-Arch Enemy) and Martin "Axe" Axenrot (Bloodbath) are welcome additions to the machine, and perform to the high standards set by the previous members, while adding a dash of their own styles to the delicious mix.

Overall Impression — 10
Akesson contributes a note of virtuosity to the band that had been excluded till now (he lets loose a ripping un-Opeth-y lead on Heir Apparent), and while Axenrot lacks the jazz sensibility of Lopez, he makes up for it with pure blunt force trauma, as well as a surprising knack for a poppy beat (just listen to his tasteful, head-nodding breakdown in Lotus Eater at the 5:45 mark). Opeth is always pushing the envelope, and Watershed can seamlessly transition from steamrolling death metal to anthemic arena rock, to off-the-wall prog, to poignantly vulnerable acoustic balladry, to freaking jazz fusion at the drop of a hat. The guessing game keeps each minute pregnant with possibility and hunger for more, all the while sounding like no band but Opeth. I'm convinced anything these guys touch turns to gold, and they can simply do no wrong as long as they keep thriving. It's just a bummer about the shortened length, but you know what they say about a good act: Always leave em' wanting more.

7 comments sorted by best / new / date

    JacksonShredder
    @Mr_CiNiC BTBAM and Opeth? Im not really sure I see the common factor here. I mean you could consider them both progressive but besides that they're not really comparable
    Mellatronix
    Mikael Akerfeldt said: i cant believe the lotus eater, i have never ever heard anything like it. it is by far the best song released in the last 40 years, i wish i could listen to that song 24/7 for the rest of my life
    i totally agree with you there mickie, i luv you
    OrganicCage
    Mr_CiNiC wrote: Way too goddamn random. I mean, Jesus, I just want a song that isn't a 64-piece rubix cube. I just want a straight up song, not him being bipolar with his moods, singing and riffs.
    Your looking in the wrong Genre buddy.
    osiris12
    I like this album, but it just doesn't touch Ghost Reveries for me. Blackwater Park is my second to that, at least until I get some more Opeth
    oTOOLo
    burden is the most amazing thing i have ever heard.... E V E R
    SGofawesome
    The Lotus Eater still remains to be one of my favorite songs by Opeth. They can do no wrong.
    Mr_CiNiC
    BWP wins, better than this a million times. I strongly disliked this album. Way too goddamn random. I mean, Jesus, I just want a song that isn't a 64-piece rubix cube. I just want a straight up song, not him being bipolar with his moods, singing and riffs. And BtBaM > Opeth.